16 Must Try Ice Cream Sandwiches

Remember eating ice cream sandwiches as a kid? You have the vanilla ice cream and chocolate wafers. Boring! There are so many ways you can make ice cream sandwich recipes. You don’t even have to use wafers. You can make ice cream sandwiches with everything from donuts to cookies to even pound cake. The sky’s the limit. You also don’t have to use vanilla ice cream. Get creative and try different combos. Below you’ll find 16 must-try ice cream sandwiches that are sure to make your mouth water.

16 Must Try Ice Cream Sandwiches Recipes
16 Must Try Ice Cream Sandwiches Recipes

The best part is that you can make these ahead of time and freeze until your family wants a quick treat. The trick to make them last longer is to make sure you wrap each one in plastic wrap and then place the sandwiches in an airtight container. This will help prevent the ice cream from soaking up strange freezer odors.

You can make ice cream sandwiches as gourmet or simple as you want. If you’re having a party, consider using premium ice cream with homemade cookies and maybe a drizzle or caramel or chocolate sauce. It will seriously blow your guests away.

These are also great for a birthday party. Use your child’s favorite ice cream with their favourite cookies. You can then roll the edges in sprinkles, crushed cookies, or even chopped up candy or nuts. Make them ahead of time and you’ll have less to do on the day of the party.

16 Must Try Ice Cream Sandwiches
16 Must Try Ice Cream Sandwiches

Use the recipes below to get you started and then play around with flavors. There are so many different combinations to choose from. Make a few different flavors and load up your freezer. You’ll spend a lot less making these from scratch and have a much better quality treat. Plus, you’ll know exactly what’s in them.

16 Must Try Ice Cream Sandwich Recipes

1. Perfectly Chewy, Ice Cream Sandwich Chocolate Chip Cookie

2. Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich

3. Reese’s Stuffed Ice Cream Sandwiches

4. Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches

5. Homemade Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe

6. Key Lime Yogurt Ice Cream Sandwiches

7. Donut Ice Cream Sandwich

8. Chocolate Ice Cream Sandwich Cookies

9. Easy Homemade Ice Cream Sandwiches

10. Chocolate-Strawberry Muffin Ice Cream Sandwiches

11. Salted Chocolate Chunk & Toffee Ice Cream Sandwiches

12. Snickerdoodle Ice Cream Sandwiches

13. Funfetti Ice Cream Sandwiches

14. Brownie Sandwich Cookies with Salted Caramel Buttercream

15. German Chocolate Ice Cream Sandwiches

16. Dulce De Leche Ice Cream Sandwiches

Lyne is a Certified Infant Massage Instructor (CIMI), Certified Professional Wedding Consultant, and an Event Planner. It has always been her dream to create a website dedicated just for Moms since her children were young. Thus, after 10 years, she finally accomplished it, and the Ottawa Mommy Club was born in May 2011. She loves all things Disney and is an avid chocoholic. She was also the Queen B of the BConnected Conference, Canada's Digital Influencer and social media Conference in Ottawa and Toronto.She coordinated the Annual Infant Information Day/Early Years Expo for the City of Ottawa for 8 years. She was also the co-chair of the Navan for Kraft Hockeyville 2009-2011 committee that organized five community events within 6 months, and helped Navan reach the top 10 finalists in Canada. In April 2011, she received the City of Ottawa Mayor's City Builder Award.

Related Posts


  1. Looking through theses the one I would love to try is the “Brownie Cookie Nutella Ice Cream Sandwiches with Salted Caramel” looks and sounds so good.

  2. Great weather for these, good to enjoy at picnic, just make sure to bring ice packs or an electric cooler. If temps get any higher, I’m opening my 4L tub of vanilla ice cream ha!

  3. All of these recipes look soooo good! I haven’t had ice cream sanwiches for a while. I think I’ll try the Reese’s Stuffed Ice Cream Sandwiches first.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Stay Connected


Recent Stories

Frozen Fruit Cups: The Ultimate Summer Treat

Frozen Fruit Cups are the ultimate summer treat. They are packed with healthy fruits and frozen to perfection for a sweet way...

Squirrel Paper Craft with Printable Template

This paper squirrel craft with printable template is such a cute project that you might go a little nutty for it! Kids...

The Best Supplies to Donate For Back To School

Back to school season is upon us! But as we go out and shop for our own children, we need to consider...

Summer Learning with DK Canada Books – Review #Giveaway ~ CAN 09/11

Summer learning with DK Canada books! They gifted us with three fun books this month to read up on discoveries, inventions, and...

Shrimp Cobb Salad Recipe

This Shrimp Cobb Salad is a healthy and flavourful dish that is loaded with shrimp, veggies, and topped with a delicious, lemon-based...