Every once in a while, I try something out just for fun or for a change of pace and it turns out to be an addiction for me. I just started making this chocolate stuffed cookie ice cream sandwich recipe and I don’t know when I will ever be able to stop!

Easy Dessert Limited Only By Freezer Space
The kicker for me is how easily I can make a whole lot of these cookie ice cream sandwiches at once. They are easy to store in the freezer and there is little to no prep I have to do in the kitchen. The hardest thing is letting the ice cream refreeze, but I promise you, you will get through this. Making these intoxicatingly decadent ice cream sandwiches requires you to spread softened ice cream across a baking sheet. Then when it’s frozen again, you simply cut it with a cookie-cutter and sandwich the little ice cream circles between two too-good-to-be-true chocolate stuffed chocolate cookies.
What Are Chocolate Stuffed Cookies?
Chocolate stuffed cookies are thicker cookies stuffed with gooey chocolate inside. They’re like the lava cake of cookies. Think about the difference between a scoop of ice cream and a scoop of ice cream topped with fudge and sprinkles. Chocolate stuffed cookies are an essential part of this recipe, but you can use other cookies to make the ice cream sandwich. Chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich is a a very popular choice.

The most important thing is more the size of the cookie in relation to the cookie cutter you use for the ice cream; however, chocolate stuffed cookies add an extra richness to this homemade ice cream sandwich recipe that makes it more enjoyable. You can buy chocolate stuffed cookies at the store, or you can make them at home. The benefit of homemade chocolate stuffed cookies is that you can size them with the same cookie cutter.
If You Don’t Have A Cookie Cutter…
This recipe is great because it lets you make several cookie ice cream sandwiches at once with hardly any trouble at all; however, you may not have the right size cookie cutter for the job and you may be reluctant to buy a new one. If this is the case, you can still use all the ingredients here to make individual chocolate stuffed cookie ice cream sandwiches. Simply spread the desired amount of softened ice cream onto one cookie and add another one to the top.
Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich with Chocolate Stuffed Cookies
- Prep time: 10 minutes
- Total time: overnight

Chocolate Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Ingredients
- 1L tub of chocolate ice cream
- Chocolate stuffed chocolate cookies or your favourite chocolate chips or chocolate cookies (these can be bought at the store or homemade)
Equipment Needed
- Round cookie cutter that matches the size of the cookie
- Parchment lined tray
How To Make Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches
Step 1: Let ice cream melt slightly until it is able to be spread onto a parchment lined tray. Freeze overnight.
Step 2: When you are ready to assemble the ice cream sandwiches cut out circles of ice cream and then place it between the cookies.
Step 3: Place cookies back in freezer until ready to serve.

I hope you enjoyed my Chocolate Stuffed Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe as much as I did! If you make it, please share your photos with us on Facebook or Twitter! Also, check out all of our other recipes!

Chocolate Stuffed Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich Recipe
Equipment
- Round cookie cutter that matches the size of the cookie
- Parchment lined tray
Ingredients
- 1 L tub of chocolate ice cream
- 20 Chocolate stuffed chocolate cookies or your favourite chocolate chips or chocolate cookies these can be bought at the store or homemade
Instructions
- Step 1: Let ice cream melt slightly until it is able to be spread onto a parchment lined tray. Freeze overnight.
- Step 2: When you are ready to assemble the ice cream sandwiches cut out circles of ice cream and then place it between the cookies.
- Step 3: Place cookies back in freezer until ready to serve.
This would be fun to make with my granddaughter, she would love these.
My granddaughter would really like these and they would be fun to make as well.